Article by: Joey aka The Padawan Collector & Dave at Toy Store Guide
On September 27th a beloved toy spot closed.
A place that had become a center for the collecting community.
NinjaXchange at the Mershops North County Mall in Escondido, California, was a multi-vendor expo that was open on weekends. The business, made up of dozens of smaller businesses, had taken over one of the empty anchor locations of the mall left vacant by a now defunct big box store. NinjaXchange describes itself as a place “passionate about bringing together collectors and enthusiasts from all over the place to celebrate their love for rare and unique items”.

Since opening the store has succeeded in becoming just that, a gathering place for collectors of all fandoms. Inside every booth can sell something different, of course toys of all ages, but also trading cards, video games, really anything you might hope to find at any of the large conventions, except you can visit every weekend. Throw in celebrity signings, trade nights, and tournaments and it is no wonder that a sense of community developed.

Sadly, we too often have to report that toy stores are closing and take them off of the site, but why and how did a place so successful have to close? For that story let’s refer to Star Wars expert Joey, known as The Padawan Collector, who would often visit NinjaXchange and released a video of his investigation of the controversy surrounding the NinjaXchange closing.
Joey built and runs the website thepadawancollector.com, which is an online guide to Star Wars action figures and toys.
“I love to shop local and support my community’s local shops, vendors, and collectibles shows. Even when I travel to other cities, I always research where the local toy shops are, who owns them, and what they specialize in. I just wanted to make these videos in hopes that people would support their local small businesses.”
Watch more videos from The Padawan Collector on his YouTube Channel HERE
“Why This Collectible Show Is Being Forced to Close?”
Good news is that NinjaXchange still has two locations throughout southern California.
We have been to and profiled the NinjaXchange location inside The Shoppes at Carlsbad Mall in Carlsbad, California. The other location that is still open is at the Canyon Crossings Mall in Riverside, California. The owners are extremely proud of what they built when it comes to both the businesses and the community and have promised to find a new location in the area with hopes to keep everyone together.

The most important point that Joey makes in his video is that the closing of NinjaXchange is “…this story isn’t just about one collectibles show in San Diego County. It’s about what happens when the places where our communities gather suddenly disappear.” The Padawan Collector asks the question, “If it can happen here, could it happen to your collecting community?”
Obviously toy stores or collectible shows closing (being forced to close) hurts our community by taking away a gathering place. But this issue can be just one example of similar actions occurring anywhere in society…
Be sure to follow The Padawan Collector on YouTube, Instagram, and thepadawancollector.com
The Padawan Collector’s video essay speaks volumes about the difficulties independent toy stores and the toy community face, below is the transcript of the mini-documentary.
This transcript was auto-generated. Please excuse any typos or grammatical errors.
This place is shutting down, it’s closing, and the reason why… Doesn’t make any sense. What if somebody told you that your favorite toy shop was closing? Not because people stopped coming. Not because the business was failing. Not because the business couldn’t afford the rent, but because somebody decided that the people coming through those doors weren’t the people they wanted.
This is the story of a collectible show being forced to close. Let’s go. There’s a controversy brewing right here in Escondido, California. As if living in California didn’t create enough controversy. Inside North County Mall is NinjaXchange, a massive collectible marketplace filled with independent vendors selling toys, trading cards, comics, video games, memorabilia, and just about everything else collectors obsess over.
And on September 27th, this place is closing. But this just isn’t a story about one collectible show. This one should hit home close to you, somewhere near you. There’s probably a comic shop, a toy store, a record shop, a convention, an arcade, a flea market, some weird little place that doesn’t look important on a corporate spreadsheet, but means everything to the people who go there.
And if a community like this can disappear, yours can too. If you’ve never been to a place like NinjaXchange, simply calling it a store doesn’t really explain what this is. This is what collectors sometimes call a collectible show or a collectibles marketplace. Instead of one company owning all the merchandise, you have a group of independent vendors who rent their own spaces under one roof.
Think of it almost like a permanent collector swap meet. One vendor might specialize in vintage Star Wars, another has Pokemon cards, a lot of Pokemon cards, another sells comics, video games, Funko Pops, sports memorabilia, sneakers. Every few feet you’re essentially walking into another small business. And if you’re familiar with Southern California, probably the best known example is Frank and Son Collectible Show in the city of Industry near LA.
Places like Frank and Son and NinjaXchange here in Escondido bring dozens of independent sellers together in one location, and that model does something incredibly important. It lowers the barrier to become a small business owner. Opening your own traditional retail store is really expensive. First, you need a building, insurance, utilities, fixtures, inventory, employees, and of course, rent. But in a collectible marketplace like NinjaXchange, an entrepreneur can rent a smaller space and build a business inside an already established location.
Maybe you start with a couple of display cases and some vintage toys. People start recognizing you. They come back, you develop regular customers, you build a reputation, and suddenly that thing you are selling out of your garage or spare bedroom becomes a real business. But something else happens, a community forms around it, because collectors just don’t come here to buy things, they come here to talk about them. You come looking for a toy, and somehow you spend 45 minutes talking to somebody about the toys you had when you were ten years old. I’ve done that more times than I like to admit. You start seeing the same people every weekend. Vendors know collectors. Collectors know vendors. Collectors start knowing each other.
Friendships form, and eventually you realize something. You may have originally come here because of the stuff, but you keep coming back because of the people. That’s when a retail space becomes something much bigger. It becomes a community. It becomes a safe place. And that’s why what’s happening to Ninja Exchange really matters. Because when a place like NinjaXchange disappears, you’re not closing one business. You’re potentially disrupting dozens of them. And that’s where this story gets complicated. Because according to NinjaXchange, the business wasn’t collapsing. They wanted to stay. In fact, according to co-founder Josh Cha, NinjaXchange had renewed its agreement and invested roughly $10,000 installing a new storefront sign. Then, Cha says the very next day mall management exercised what’s called a recapture clause.
Basically, it’s a provision allowing the landlord, under the terms of the agreement, to take the space back. NinjaXchange was out, and according to NinjaXchange, on August 20th, they were informed another tenant would be taking over the space. They didn’t simply pick up and leave. They fought to stay. Cha told the North County Pipeline that NinjaXchange offered to pay an additional 10,000 per month.
NinjaXchange even offered to change their business model and open seven days a week. Right now, they’re only open on the weekends. And according to Cha, the answer was still no. But now we’re getting to the part of the story that has collectors angry. NinjaXchange says mall management told them their expo wasn’t considered visually appealing enough for the direction the mall wanted to go.
Think about that for a second. Not enough customers? Apparently not. Not enough money? They offered more. Not enough operating days? They offered seven. The issue, according to NinjaXchange, was something much harder to quantify. Image char has made an even more troubling allegation in an interview again with North County Pipeline. Cha claimed that during discussions, a representative characterized the business as horrendous and made a disparaging comment about whether NinjaXchange’s clientele was the type of customers who would patronize one of the mall’s restaurants.
That’s Cha’s account, and that’s important because I wasn’t in that room. Neither were you. The North County Pipeline reported that it contacted a mall representative for a comment, but did not receive a response before this story was published. Nor before this video is going to air. So I’m not going to tell you what happened behind closed doors. I’m gonna show you what’s happening out there and let you ask the same question.
I’m asking why. And there’s another side to this. NinjaXchange normally operates Friday through Sunday rather than seven days a week. From a shopping mall’s perspective, having a large tenant closed Monday through Thursday is an ideal. Mall management has every right to think about what mix of tenants it really wants. And North County Mall itself is changing. The property has been undergoing a broader transformation with major new retail, dining and entertainment uses planned or proposed.
Gotta tell both sides of the story. So maybe management genuinely believes a different tenant is better for the long term future of this mall. That’s just business. But here’s where the argument becomes difficult. According to char, when management raised the seven day issue, he offered to open for seven days when money was an issue and they thought he was paying a low rent.
He offered more money than the incoming tenant, and NinjaXchange says that still wasn’t enough. At some point you have to ask what exactly is the problem they were trying to solve? There’s another reason why this matters. When you look at NinjaXchange from the outside. You only see one storefront, but when that storefront closes for good. Dozens of small businesses also have to close.
These aren’t multinational corporations deciding whether to move a location from one shopping center to another. These are vendors. Some of these vendors are individuals, families, collectors who turn something they loved into something that helps pay the bills. And in this economy, anything helps. A marketplace like this gives someone who could never afford their own traditional retail storefront an opportunity to become a real entrepreneur.
NinjaXchange says some businesses that started within this marketplace have gone on to become permanent mall tenants themselves. That’s the irony. The thing that may not look like traditional retail can actually create traditional retailers. And on September 27th. All of that changes. And this is where I want you to forget about NinjaXchange for a moment.
Think about your favorite place. Maybe it’s the comic shop that you visited for 20 years. Maybe it’s a store where the owner knows your name. Maybe it’s the record shop where you discovered your favorite album. Maybe it’s the flea market you used to visit with your dad. Maybe it’s the hobby shop where your kid bought their first Pokemon card. Picture that place. Picture the people you’ve met there the Saturday mornings.
The conversations, the memories. Now imagine somebody telling you we’re closing. Naturally you think because business must have been bad. But imagine finding out that people were still coming in droves. The owners actually wanted to stay. They were willing to pay more. They were willing to change their hours. And none of it mattered. Suddenly, this little story that’s happening in Escondido, California, doesn’t feel quite so little anymore.
The internet has made collecting easier than it has ever been. I can find almost any Star Wars figure I want without leaving my house. I can buy it on eBay. Pay for it. Have it delivered. Done. Efficient. Absolutely memorable. Absolutely not. Places like NinjaXchange provide something Amazon and eBay never can. Serendipity. Walking around a corner and seeing something you haven’t seen since 1983, or finding something you didn’t even know existed.
Meeting the person who knows everything about it, and then spending the next 20 minutes talking about why it matters. Collecting may be about objects, but collecting communities are obviously about people, and communities need places to visit. Ninja exchanges final day here at North County Mall is Sunday, September 27th, 2026. If you had a chance to visit and say goodbye before it closed, I hope you had a chance to go there and wish the vendors well and buy something.
And also just take a moment to walk the space. This doesn’t appear to be the end of NinjaXchange. The organizers say their priority is keeping the vendors together and finding the Escondido community another home. And that’s probably the most important part of this story. Landlords can always take back a retail space. They can remove the signs, they can change the tenant, but they don’t own the community that formed inside it.
And maybe that’s the lesson here. Collectors sometimes spend a lot of time protecting the things that we actually collect that we forget. We also have to protect the places that allow collecting to thrive. So support your local toy stores. Support your local comic shops. Support local conventions. Support the guy with 12 folding tables and way too many action figures.
Because these places don’t exist simply because we love them. They exist because we show up. And when something like this happens in your community, don’t immediately grab the pitchfork. Grab something much more powerful and question why? Why is this place closing? Why is this community being displaced? Who made that decision? And what can be done differently in the future?
Because today, that question is being asked about NinjaXchange in Escondido tomorrow. It could be the place you love. September 27th isn’t necessarily the end of this community. It’s just the day they’re being forced to find somewhere else together and wherever that turns out to be. I’m pretty sure collectors are going to find it. We always do. And as always, my friends, thank you. And I will see you next time.
